Visitor Flow Management for Balanced Tourism Growth

With sustainability the cornerstone of tourism strategies, we are investigating the best approaches to build transparent models that fully account for the impact on society and the environment.

Want to join? Talk to us

Overview

Define
Define
Collectively defining the key challenges, pain-points and opportunities to be explored further in the workstream.
Research
Research
Applying research methods to gain perspective and a better understanding of key developments and insights.
Develop
Develop
Building solutions helping members address key challenges and collectively further their work.
Prototype
Prototype
Putting initial prototype solutions into action, assessing their value working towards future iterations.
Complete
Complete
Logical conclusion of Workstream when no longer needed, archive of work retained for reference.

Overtourism has become a perennial challenge facing destinations. Despite a desire among tourists to explore and immerse themselves within destinations, tourists tend to congregate in the same locations. This creates significant challenges for destination management to avoid carrying capacity being exceeded.

Destinations are responding to this challenge in innovative ways, utilising technology, data and/or strategic marketing activities to shape tourist behaviour and help them locate undiscovered hidden gems. This Workstream aims to discover the most effective approaches to spreading the benefits of tourism across the entire destination.

Challenges

This section outlines the key challenges the Workstream seeks to understand better and the impactful results it aims to achieve in addressing them.

Seasonality

While peak seasons bring substantial economic benefits, this also makes it difficult to implement measures that might reduce visitor numbers during these periods given the large number of businesses that are reliant on this income. This creates a delicate balancing act between maximising economic gains and ensuring a sustainable and enjoyable visitor experience.

Obtaining Data

Monitoring visitor flows necessitates a robust data foundation, encompassing a range of relevant sources. However, acquiring these datasets can be costly and they often provide insights into past behaviour rather than real-time information. Yet, to truly get a complete and up-to-date understanding of visitor patterns, datasets must be combined to create comprehensive indexes that enable more granular analysis.

Resistance from Stakeholders

The implementation of effective visitor flow management strategies can often be hindered by resistance from stakeholders. When stakeholders have differing priorities or are reluctant to embrace change, it can create friction and hinder progress. A lack of awareness about the full extent of the challenge and the complexities of managing visitor flows also makes it difficult to gain buy-in and support for necessary measures. This can lead to arduous negotiations and difficulties in balancing diverse expectations.

Reliance on Outdated Management Tools

Technological limitations can hinder the ability of DMOs to adopt the latest tools, often due to high costs and a lack of internal expertise. This can result in a reliance on outdated technologies that may not provide the necessary insights or capabilities for effective visitor flow management.

Unpredictable Visitor Patterns

Social media has become a powerful tool for inspiring travel, with tourists increasingly relying on word-of-mouth recommendations and trending destinations. Such communications are often beyond the control of DMOs, potentially counteracting their marketing messaging of connecting with local cultures and showcasing hidden gems.

Political Remits

The traditional remit of DMOs centres on increasing visitor numbers through marketing campaigns. Typically being publicly funded organisations, political willpower from governments strongly influences DMO strategies meaning there is limited scope to adjust priorities in the short-term and react to changing visitor behaviour.

Outputs

The outputs are defined and later refined by members of the Workstream and serve as the guiding objectives defining the group's scope of work and priorities.

Best Practices Guide

A detailed overview of the visitor management approaches currently being undertaken by destinations and the key learning outcomes from their implementation. This will include an overview of the data sources and technological solutions that help destination management.

  1. Extended research files with reporting, strategy, planning and test data shared privately with other Workstream Members.
  2. Analysis of data sources and technologies used by destinations to monitor and manage visitor flows effectively.
  3. Key learnings and actionable recommendations for other destinations to adapt and implement similar approaches.
Carrying Capacity Framework

To develop a standardised framework for assessing destination carrying capacity, which will provide a consistent and comparable approach for informing decision-making. This framework will enable international benchmarking and a granular understanding of the different factors that influence carrying capacity.

  1. Research Repository: A curated collection and summary of research papers, reports and strategic documents focused on visitor management approaches.
  2. Data Sources Directory: Exploring the diverse range of data sources employed by destinations and their potential applications.
  3. Indicator Analysis: A detailed examination of KPIs and metrics that shape destination management.
  4. Defining Criteria: Creating a standardised reporting framework for urban and rural destinations.
Visitor Sentiment Mapping

To ensure that visitor management approaches align with the needs and preferences of different visitor segments, their acceptance levels to management solutions will be mapped to inform communication strategies and help DMOs tailor messaging to achieve a stronger impact.

  1. Visitor Segmentation: Identify and categorise visitor segments based on their characteristics, such as demographics, travel motivations and preferences.
  2. Assess Acceptance Levels: Measure the acceptance levels of each segment for different visitor management solutions, including marketing and educational campaigns, digital solutions and visitor levies or restrictions.
  3. Develop Tailored Messaging: Create targeted messaging strategies that resonate with the unique needs and preferences of each visitor segment.
AI-Assisted Visitor Management

To effectively manage visitor flows and minimise their impact on natural resources, a robust AI tool will be identified for analysing complex datasets, modelling environmental impacts and providing accurate predictions.

  1. Define Key Indicators: Determine the relevant environmental indicators to be monitored, such as air quality, water pollution and biodiversity, and their baselines and capacities.
  2. Evaluating AI Tools: Research and evaluate various AI tools to determine their capability in analysing complex datasets and review their respective strengths and weaknesses.
Digital Twin for Visitor Flow Management

To gain practical insights into the complex interplay between visitor flows, destination management strategies and climate change, a digital twin tool will be developed to simulate scenarios.

  1. Build a Digital Twin: Create a virtual representation of a destination, incorporating key features such as geography, infrastructure and visitor attractions.
  2. Define Parameters and Metrics: Identify relevant parameters and metrics, including visitor flows, resource consumption, weather conditions and the impact of climate change.
  3. Simulate Scenarios: Conduct simulations to evaluate the potential outcomes of different visitor management strategies under various conditions, such as comparing the implications of policy approaches.

Meetings

The working group participants meet regularly to openly share ideas and discuss the project's progress and move forward with each phase of the initiative. Here's an overview of the most recent meetings.

Inaugural Session

September 6, 2024
TBC
TBC
Online
Pending
2 Hours

Participants

This Workstream is just getting started.. Check back soon